SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Weekly Poll: 'We Want Cheaters! We Want Cheaters!'

Written by TVSA Team from the blog TVSA Polls on 30 Jan 2008
Favourite this post


When offered a choice of 10 reality shows, TVSA readers decided the one they would most want a South African version of is Cheaters.

In the 5th weekly TVSA Poll the question posed to readers was as follows: "Which international reality show would you like a local version of?"

Cheaters, the American version of which airs on e.tv, came out tops, garnering 126 votes out of a total of 547 (23 percent of the votes).

The only other show to crack more than 100 votes was America's Next Top Model (which also airs on e.tv), which would naturally become South Africa's Next Top Model should it ever get made.

SABC3's The Amazing Race came third with 90 votes, although sadly it's highly unlikely a copycat version of the American one could ever be made here - the cost of it is far too prohibitive.

Instead we'll have to continue to suffer through the occasional weak attempts to make something similar, such as the stupendously bad Magic Cape Race which mercifully ended early in January.

These are the full results of the poll:

No. Show Votes Percentage Channel
1. Cheaters 126 23% e.tv
2. America's Next Top Model 101 18% e.tv
3. The Amazing Race 90 16% SABC3
4. The Bachelor 85 16% e.tv, M-Net Series
5. Extreme Makeover: HE 75 14% M-Net, M-Net Series
6. America's Got Talent 23 4% M-Net Series
7. Top Chef 18 3% M-Net Series
8. Project Runway 12 2% M-Net Series
9. Last Comic Standing 9 2% M-Net Series
10. The Contender 8 1% SABC2, actionX

Cheaters would be fun, although life-threatening to anyone who took part. All the more fun for us, of course.

A local version of The Bachelor would be interesting, if we could find a decent bachelor. Interracial relationships would be the order of the day, since the bachelor would certainly be a different race to at least some of the girls vying for his attentions.

Extreme Makeover: Home Edition has its appeal, but only because so much money is spent on making over the (invariably huge) homes in the US version. We marvel at how awesome all their new stuff is.

Here we'd get some dodgy contractor who would use cheap materials and have the misfortune of having the new flatscreen TV "fall off the back" of his truck.

It could only work if a lot of money was spent on it, which is probably true of all these shows.

America's Got Talent? We tried that with the awful 30 Seconds to Fame on SABC3 in 2004, which did nothing but prove that South Africans most definitely do not have talent. Or if they do, the show sure didn't find them.

Top Chef would be fun with a local flavour (this week's task: cook us something using pap, wors, Mrs Balls chutney and, of course, some fennel); Project Runway would give local designers a huge boost (hopefully); and Last Comic Standing would be nothing but excrutiating.

What we can't understand is why The Contender came last in the poll, especially considering South Africa's historical association with boxing.

We've produced numerous world champions over the decades and have always had a very strong stable of boxers who compete internationally and locally.

Yet although the show is set in the world of boxing, it's less about the sport and more about the individuals - their emotions, their mental strength, their hard-luck stories and their desperate fight for survival using the only means they have at their disposal: their fists.

Unlike most reality shows this one features contestants who have genuine talent and skill in their field, which heightens the reality aspect of the show. When they lose they can't just shrug their shoulders and say "Oh well" - they have to take that loss into the real world, and carry it with them.

It's a heart-wrenching, inspirational show, and particularly appropriate to South Africans. It's our pick of the poll.

The next Weekly TVSA Poll is now live on the right hand side of the site. This week's question is a simple one: "Which broadcaster has the best website?"

Take a look at their various websites and when doing so judge them on their look, their ease of use, the information they contain, the features they have and any other criteria you like.




7 Comments

nonkez
30 Jan 2008 02:14

yo, ppl would kill each other here in mzansi, wat wld be funny though is the fact that not many south africans hv cars like in the US, so there wld be no running away frm the camera's. ha ha ha !!!!! its funny already!

alex
30 Jan 2008 03:09

That was a really good poll idea. I voted for Cheaters, on a purely trash and scandal basis. Of course it would probably turn murderous, but I just know it would be hella entertaining seeing our locals chase each other in the the streets, hurling abuse.

I totally agree about The Contender though. Its inspirational stuff and would fit in well with our demographic. But for it to be any good would require a really genius editor/director type set-up. What makes the US version so compelling is the editing and interweaving of people's stories. And the diversity of the contenders is great as well. SA versions of US reality shows have been hampered by bad production values and this could be an obstacle.

However, with Cheaters, this wouldn't be a factor at all! The worse it is, the better :D   

belz
30 Jan 2008 03:14

I voted for cheaters coz i also thot it would be fun to see people moor each other ngezagila, hihihi, yah it would be funny indeed.

lepogo
30 Jan 2008 03:19

Cheaters would be scandalous,I would put the team on my Father's ass....That would make for interesting viewing.....

cleave
30 Jan 2008 05:28

Well for those that live in Soweto. Jozi FM has their own version of Cheaters - uyajola. There have been casualties I tell you. Apparently it's on Thursdays.

Segololo
30 Jan 2008 10:21

LEPOGO!!!

FK
04 Aug 2008 07:47

Well for those that live in Soweto. Jozi FM has their own version of Cheaters - uyajola. There have been casualties I tell you. Apparently it's on Thursdays. @ Cleave

This Soweto Radio version of Cheaters U yajola is now available on DSTV Audio channel 178, Thursday 10pm.  I tuned in last week and I was shocked. A 42 year old woman (Lizzy), married with 2 kids - 1 (Keke) from previous relationship and the other emendweni).

Keke is 22yrs old and she is a beauty.  Lizzy came to Jozi FM because her husbank (Billy) no longer have time for her.  He no longer touches her.  The last time he touched her was 8 months ago (ucansi).

It became apparent that the reason Billy is no longer interested in her, is because he is sleeping with Keke and they are expecting a child.  All this is revealed by Keke, telling her mother (Lizzy) that if she can't take care of her husband, yena (Keke) will.

The presenter (Dr Love) did not have much to say except - AMANYALA.


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Saturday 23 November 2024

Mabaso Family Reunion drops on Netflix and Killer Front Page begins a run on Wethu.


Jhanak Teasers - December 2024

Tejas threatens Jhanak: "Either you marry me or I'll kill Aniruddha." True love. NOT.


Muvhango Teasers - December 2024

Susan gets hypnotised and flees what she sees. She returns to Venda to represent the royal family’s interests.


Diepe Waters 3 Teasers - December 2024

Perspective versus fact. Jacques and Johan come to a conclusion about Theresa.


New on TV today: Friday 22 November 2024

Bread & Roses on Apple TV+ tells the plight of Afghan women as Nat Geo Wild camps out on Africa's Blood River.


Scandal! Teasers - December 2024

A wedding proposal, a familiar face returns and Ndumiso basks in the glory of his apparent heroism.


Binnelanders Teasers - December 2024

Joe tells his sister about his visit to their father’s mistress. Ouch!


New on TV today: Thursday 21 November

BBC Earth takes you around the Solar System and a Wicked special airs on E! ahead of the film premiere.


My Naam is Farah Teasers - December 2024

Immigration officials turn up at Farah’s home. And then she receives a call from a ghost.


Survivor 45: See who lovestruck Austin's dating now

Are Austin and Dee still together? Find out here as we reflect on the season.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.