SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Idols 9 final showdown

Written by makisto from the blog Frankly Speaking on 25 Nov 2013
Favourite this post


The gloves come off in the penultimate episode, it’s a war and only one person can come out victorious. Who will be crowned South Africa’s 2013 Idol?

b_m_warb_m_war

They have had to beat thousands of hopefuls from across the country to get where they are and Brenden and Musa have done it with grace, until now that is. Musa was first to draw blood from Brenden after Idols producers allegedly sabotaged Brenden with some boring song called Jailer by Asa which the producers believe it is Brenden’s best performance of the season. Musa took the alleged Brenden sabotage as a sign of victory as producers picked the right song for him which is Ringo’s Ndiyagodola. Needless to say, Musa won round one thanks to the producers’ sabotage. Brenden tried his level best to do justice to the song but it was just boring I almost fell asleep with the remote in my hand.

top8_stage

Amid all the sabotage frenzy was a lip synching scandal by the other top 8 who performed on the Moreleta auditorium stage. The booted eight girls and guys performed a collabo and set the stage alight, well except that they were lip syncing. It was however great to see them back on the Idols stage doing their thang.

brenden_semis

Brenden took the producers’ sabotage with a pinch of salt and came back with his guns blazing when he performed his second song which he personally picked as his best performance of the season and indeed it is his best. His supporters sighed a sigh of relief after they saw their Idol redeem himself by rendering Rihanna’s Stay from his top 18 battle. Pulling no punches, Brenden reminded the hormonal teenagers why they fell in love with him in the first place. This time around, he paid special attention to every single note and performed way much better than he originally performed during the top 18.

musa_top2

Despite his “fans” causing a cacophony shouting his name in the auditorium, Musa cracked under pressure probably after hearing how Brenden won back the love from his supporters. Musa chose his personal best performance as Sexual Healing by Marvin Gay. In my humble opinion, that was not his personal best and he could have chosen a better song. In any case, Musa’s second performance wasn’t all that and Twitter went abuzz on how Joyous Celebration should sign him.

At this point in time, the two contestants were even with both having equally bruised the other, vocal bruises that is, you get what I am saying.

proverb_performs

Then Judge Unathi Msengana also joined in on the war bringing out her claws to sting host Proverb showing him he should not get comfortable at the hosting seat proving she can replace him at any given point in time. She did so with grace when she introduced the show’s Musical Director RJ Benjamin and Proverb’s collabo with 1st Project. It was like the Coca-Cola Popstars back in 2004 all over again when Unathi hosted.

brenden_smi

The final round between Musa and Brenden comprised of their so called singles and the music video were nothing short of Ford Fiesta product placement. Anyway who can blame the poor producers, we all know how they need that sponsorship, we cannot have an Idol being like Lira back in the days when she used a taxi to go to gigs. Taxis are for us ordinary Joes.



As I was saying about Brenden and Musa’s singles, both singles are nothing short of 5FM market. I am not even sure their music is for YFM (Brenden fans) and Radio Pulpit (Musa fans). Forget about them targeting the affluent Metro FM listeners, let alone being played on Channel O.

Brenden’s Single is called Fingerprints and it was very difficult for the audience to connect with the song as they thought Ben10 was singing for white votes. I do get this is Idols but let’s be honest here, white people have long stopped voting at this stage of the competition.

muuuuuusaaaaa

For me, Musa’s single, I Still Feel It, also did nothing to connect with me as a black person who prefers to buy the real deal. Whether Musa will win this or not, is not as clear cut as some twitterers suggest. Both he and Brenden have equal chances to win or lose this, despite Brenden being sabotaged.

sonke_sonke

This is not the first time Idols sabotages a contestant. Last year, Tshidi Tenyane was set up for failure by producers of the show who had over five hours of footage (I would imagine)from her home coming and when they had to choose only 90 seconds, they chose the infamous “Don’t jump on me” line. We have seen it again not so long ago with Sonke when judge Randal sabotaged him by giving him some lame song to perform. And last night the producers have outdone themselves again.

Perhaps also worth mentioning in this season is that we are on a break from the so called race card by blacks decrying the lack of a black person in the final round. Whether blacks dominating the top four will be a trend remains to be seen. However, at this point in time, it’s war between Brenden and Musa. May the best Idol win.


Shows in this post: Idols



59 Comments

Ms Opinionated
25 Nov 2013 11:41

Makiso u bosso wena!!! this is a great review and a true reflection of Sunday's show. 

Sabotage has become a norm on Idols Sonke who is a great singer also got his share. Brenden thou not as vocally strong as these two these two (Musa and Sonke) is a musician. With no doubt Musa is a great singer, perormer but i strongly feel he has been favoured!


#TeamBrenden waya waya!

Sana Lwam
25 Nov 2013 11:42

Oh please Makisto! Akho Sonke osabitage-iweyo apha. That boy was just to squeaky well the Xhosa word to actually describe him was "ebemanzi" too much for Idols.

Mrs Chix
25 Nov 2013 12:28

I agree about Tshidi, poor girl that was sabotage at its best. I thought Musa's Ringo was a sabotage, he was lucky coz he is just vocally good. Brenden also did justice to Jailer, even though it was not that good, he tried

Teeza
25 Nov 2013 12:47

Akhe si voteni maqela. Time is of the essence. I did not mind Jailer because it also showcases B's other talents as a muso, even tho' I'd have loved "All of me" or "Woman's work" he NAILED "Stay" Vote, vote and vote sum more!!

Ankonisaho
25 Nov 2013 12:52

That Musa Song i can feel it being played on metro fm on sundays...

beautybrain
25 Nov 2013 13:50

kwaaaaaaa. U can talk hey,let's keep voting BRENDEN #01

tha - bang
25 Nov 2013 15:41

yesterdays show was a total bore and only brenden stay was something amazing. although i thought he did a better job performing asa's jailer this time around unlike the first.

i agree with you makitso on the songs they are lame,no wonder idol winners dont go beyond the show music wise

tha - bang
25 Nov 2013 15:42

btw the self promotion by RJ Benjamina nd Pro...tsk tsk tsk

sanell
25 Nov 2013 16:22

I liked Brenden's single. I think its fun n funky n the lyrics in the chorus r nice. Musa's single was boring (hides from Musa's fans). Brenden's performance last night showed a lot of growth he did everything right. Only a few hours left so let's keep voting!

bubbytee
25 Nov 2013 19:46

The show was boring. What happened to there energies? Really? Well I love brenden I will vote for him. Simply cause I believe in him

Amy M
26 Nov 2013 07:10

Last week there were a few people who said that Brenden is arrogant, but did u guys see Musa on Sunday just after the show. It seemed as if Brenden was sharing a light joke with Musa and Musa looked at him and immediately igonored Brenden and started chatting to Proverb. Poor Ben10, he was so embarrased that he just kept smiling at his fans to hide his embarrasment. Now, that is what i call arrogant, ignoring Ben10 just like that. Well i hope that Brenden will win tonight. I voted like mad for him. P.S Their singles werent that good, especially Musa's single, so country and nothing like pop material.

zam.ngcobo
26 Nov 2013 08:25

Maki I love your unbiased writing skills !!!!!

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 08:33

@ Amy i saw that, in fact i think Ben 10 was congratulating Musa and his single least he could have done was return the favour just for peace bantu hawwu..... anywho all the best to the two of them!! lets hope our votes made a diiference :)

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 08:33

@ Amy i saw that, in fact i think Ben 10 was congratulating Musa and his single least he could have done was return the favour just for peace bantu hawwu..... anywho all the best to the two of them!! lets hope our votes made a diiference :)

Goldi
26 Nov 2013 08:36

I didnt watch the show on sunday only yesterday ai i still say my money is on Ben10 even he's footrpint i like i like Musa's single not bad as well i hope Brenden will be our next SA Idol i guess will have to wait and see tonight

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 09:34

@ Tazteeq even the their twitter handles, i really hope that the followers are also voters :). 

@ Goldi lets wait for Ben 10's glory, its been a rough season Randall was going down on the boy but ube strong shem! 

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 09:34

@ Tazteeq even the their twitter handles, i really hope that the followers are also voters :). 

@ Goldi lets wait for Ben 10's glory, its been a rough season Randall was going down on the boy but ube strong shem! 

Amy M
26 Nov 2013 09:54

@Ms Opinionated. Glad that i am not the only one who saw that. Lets pray that our votes for Brenden werent in vain. What time does the show start tonight guys?

Nunumsi
26 Nov 2013 10:17

I'm holding thumbs for Brenden been voting for him since Wednesday to be our Idol 2013....

Goldi
26 Nov 2013 11:15

Go team Brenden Go errrr i think it's 7pm or 7:30 not sure but somewhere there

Zofuya
26 Nov 2013 11:30

Musa all the way.  He is a brilliant artist.

cleve
26 Nov 2013 11:36

I'm sorry but this ariticle is biased against Musa, so r u saying the only way that Musa wins is cos of the sabotage of thee producerrs??? Musa is talented he cudve been given any song he wudve slayed it. His single is better (my opinion) than Brendans' mayb its the kind of music I relate to better. If Musa wins will purely be based on his talent! Don't take that away from him. Radio Pulpit fans??? WOW!

cleve
26 Nov 2013 11:45

Musa carried himself thru the competition on vocal ability. That's how ppl fell in love with him even tho he did not fit societal views on how an idol shud look. Pure talent brought him here, effortless singing and understanding his craft and vocal abilities. Well done Brendon for getting this far, if only 2 ppl cud win. Un4fotunately has to be one. I hope its Musa! We voted its done. Wishing both the best in ur future careers!

Amy M
26 Nov 2013 12:10

@Tanx Goldi. Will be sitting in front of the telly at 19h00.

makisto
26 Nov 2013 12:41

I'm sorry but this ariticle is biased against Musa
Maki I love your unbiased writing skills !!!!!

One article, two different views. I love me some TVSA bloggers. We have different opinions and I like that, a lot

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 14:21

For me and emphasis on FOR ME there is nothing bias about this article but it is a refelc  tion of the episode in Makiso's eyes  which i agree with. sabotage is common in idols (we have seen this) and just because it never happened to Musa you will never feel our pain.

We are happy they made good song choices for Musa to shine. even if he is a good singer bad song choices can cripple you as in Sonke's case. And as versatile as Musa is seen i dont think he would have cracked it if he was given Brenden's song!

I dont see in the article where it says Musa did well purely becoz of Brenden's sabotage but it gave him an edge and I for one think contestants should be treated fairly.

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 14:21

For me and emphasis on FOR ME there is nothing bias about this article but it is a refelc  tion of the episode in Makiso's eyes  which i agree with. sabotage is common in idols (we have seen this) and just because it never happened to Musa you will never feel our pain.

We are happy they made good song choices for Musa to shine. even if he is a good singer bad song choices can cripple you as in Sonke's case. And as versatile as Musa is seen i dont think he would have cracked it if he was given Brenden's song!

I dont see in the article where it says Musa did well purely becoz of Brenden's sabotage but it gave him an edge and I for one think contestants should be treated fairly.

maddie
26 Nov 2013 15:16

There is nothing anyone can do and say that will change the mind of fans.

People loved both Musa and Brenden initially for different reasons and that's why they're still in the competition.

I find the Joyous and Radio Pulpit remarks very condescending, by the way the best artists of our time started in church, whitney houston, aretha franklin et al

Brenden is likeable and looks very humble shem but if we compare his vocals with that of Musa he does not even come close.

I love Musa's voice and he's the kinda guy I would pay good money to listen and see him perform. Different strokes for different folks

And Maki this article is not objective at all

zam.ngcobo
26 Nov 2013 15:21

Ms Opinionated you summed it well for me , Sonke was sabotaged .................... Tshidi was Sabotaged and Brended was sabotaged and ama FACTS lawo. if ungaboni hhayi inenkinga. And yes i am teamBEN10 sesivotile and now we wait for the results.

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 15:32

@Maddie id like to disagree with you a little unlike last Idols seasons people have been very much undecided about the winner hence those singles contribuited to most people making their minds up. people want to know what kind of music these people can make and most of them dont even know that they dont write the songs themselves. To create that wrong impression of Brenden's art was satabotage qha qwaba! The boy took this will grace thou and did the best he could and thats a strenght. 

@Zam kunzima kuthi coz people always say Brenden made it coz of his good looks we dont get touchie about that coz I for one know that this boy is a musician and can grow in many more ways than he has in the past few weeks!

Ms Opinionated
26 Nov 2013 15:32

@Maddie id like to disagree with you a little unlike last Idols seasons people have been very much undecided about the winner hence those singles contribuited to most people making their minds up. people want to know what kind of music these people can make and most of them dont even know that they dont write the songs themselves. To create that wrong impression of Brenden's art was satabotage qha qwaba! The boy took this will grace thou and did the best he could and thats a strenght. 

@Zam kunzima kuthi coz people always say Brenden made it coz of his good looks we dont get touchie about that coz I for one know that this boy is a musician and can grow in many more ways than he has in the past few weeks!

zam.ngcobo
26 Nov 2013 15:34

Musa is not a versatile artist he can only do one style of singing ,I mean he doesn’t even challenge himself let alone try to move his feet. I wouldn’t pay a dime for uMusa. Yes Brenden's vocal ability is limited and the reason we all know that it’s because he challenges himself while Musa is sitting in his comfort zone and everyone says the guy can sing. Mina nje i would be bored stiff after 2 songs aMusa. Cause he sings every song the same way and that is my 2cents opinion.

Nunumsi
26 Nov 2013 15:38

Counting hours for Brenden to take his crown (hope so).

zam.ngcobo
26 Nov 2013 15:52

@MsOpinionated ....................yes its like they are punishing him for being handsome and yellow boned , wazicelela yini bantu uBrenden weNkosi ??? hhayi mani leave my Ben10 alone people

makisto
26 Nov 2013 15:58

We shall talk after the crowning then

Mrs Chix
26 Nov 2013 16:21

I am scared for Musa, with all these hormonal teenagers and women **SMH**

zam.ngcobo
26 Nov 2013 16:26

YEAH LATER GUYS

mpozim
26 Nov 2013 19:24

mpozim
26 Nov 2013 19:25

let say let the best man win

makisto
26 Nov 2013 19:47

Let Brenden win this

makisto
26 Nov 2013 20:56

And Musa wins *dropsmic*

cleve
26 Nov 2013 20:58

What did we say??? Can't hear u team Brendon!!!!!! I guess musa won cos everyone else was sabotaged hehehehe! Well done both of u guys but the best man won!!!!!!!!!!! Talent #talent we did it MuSANATIoN

cleve
26 Nov 2013 20:59

Radio pulpit and Joyous here we come : D, Goodluck to both in the future

Sobza
26 Nov 2013 21:04

I said I careless who wins, I lied....I didn't want Brenden to win. Congratulations to Musa. My idol is still Sonke though

makisto
26 Nov 2013 21:07

Sonke is still my idol too Sobza

Amy M
26 Nov 2013 21:09

Sigh_:-(, i just cant believe that Musa won this competition. He looked so cool during the time they were waiting to announce da results. Its as if he knew that he would win. Brenden my heart is bleeding for u, but i strongly believe that some1 will sign him up As Alicia Keys said in one of her songs, I am going to try sleeping with a broken heart. Night y'all. Even my son is heartbroken.

Mrs Chix
26 Nov 2013 21:37

Yah neh hormones dint always know best. Well done Musa. Whether his album sell or ot he is the Idols winner Season 9. At least the 4 vote I hrew for him counted ...cheers

Mrs Chix
26 Nov 2013 21:39

Eish cellphone blogging

CoffeeD
26 Nov 2013 22:53

Musa Musa yhoyho Musa..congrats buti am glad that my votes didnt go 2 waiste

zam.ngcobo
27 Nov 2013 08:20

Congrats to d fat guy ....................................next year he'll be gracing the stage performing a gospel song just like Khaya dod last night.

zam.ngcobo
27 Nov 2013 08:22

meant did

Goldi
27 Nov 2013 08:55

The pain in Brenden's eye made my heart bleed ohh my Ben10 i wish it was you not Musa not that i dont like he's singing but my money was never on him Yes Amy he will rise he's got good chances and he's still young he'll make it :(  i slept with a broken heart self but hey it's a brand new day

Ms Opinionated
27 Nov 2013 09:11

Congrats to Musa!!!!

Eish the pain on my Ben10's eyes yesterday he could not even hide it shem. But rest assured the boy is going places and we are not consoling ourselves apho. Id live him to finish his studies since its related to music and make good music like your Zakes Bantwinis. 

Idols is just a money spinning initiative, they havent even given Musa his proces and already they are advertising for next year's auditions yhuuuuuAnd how are thy investing in winners if they have an Idol every year??

can we talk about Khaya Mthethwa??? heheheh mna i see Khaya's situation as selfishness qha!

Ms Opinionated
27 Nov 2013 09:11

Congrats to Musa!!!!

Eish the pain on my Ben10's eyes yesterday he could not even hide it shem. But rest assured the boy is going places and we are not consoling ourselves apho. Id live him to finish his studies since its related to music and make good music like your Zakes Bantwinis. 

Idols is just a money spinning initiative, they havent even given Musa his proces and already they are advertising for next year's auditions yhuuuuuAnd how are thy investing in winners if they have an Idol every year??

can we talk about Khaya Mthethwa??? heheheh mna i see Khaya's situation as selfishness qha!

Nunumsi
27 Nov 2013 09:15

Sorry Brenden hope I'll hear your music & Sonke's in future... My heart sores but it was a close call only 1000 votes from millions separating the winner.

Nunumsi
27 Nov 2013 09:20

Zam.Ngcobo my thoughts exactly even the audience was bored by Khaya's gospel perfomance on POP IDOLS show.... next year it will be Musa.... Brenden & Sonke wish you rock us like Lloyd Cele who didn't win but is doing great.

babygal
27 Nov 2013 10:11

I would have loved to see the finale with sonke and musa in it, but it was not meant to be glad musa won though, i was never brenden's fan.

khaya singing gospel on idols, seriously WTH!!!!!

babygal
27 Nov 2013 10:13

Lol Sobza, i'm with you on that one i was also hoping he does not win and he didn't.

zam.ngcobo
27 Nov 2013 14:09

can we talk about Khaya Mthethwa??? heheheh mna i see Khaya's situation as selfishness qha! 
very selfish because he was already with joyous celebration when he entered idols............................


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Saturday 23 November 2024

Mabaso Family Reunion drops on Netflix and Killer Front Page begins a run on Wethu.


Jhanak Teasers - December 2024

Tejas threatens Jhanak: "Either you marry me or I'll kill Aniruddha." True love. NOT.


Muvhango Teasers - December 2024

Susan gets hypnotised and flees what she sees. She returns to Venda to represent the royal family’s interests.


Diepe Waters 3 Teasers - December 2024

Perspective versus fact. Jacques and Johan come to a conclusion about Theresa.


New on TV today: Friday 22 November 2024

Bread & Roses on Apple TV+ tells the plight of Afghan women as Nat Geo Wild camps out on Africa's Blood River.


Scandal! Teasers - December 2024

A wedding proposal, a familiar face returns and Ndumiso basks in the glory of his apparent heroism.


Binnelanders Teasers - December 2024

Joe tells his sister about his visit to their father’s mistress. Ouch!


New on TV today: Thursday 21 November

BBC Earth takes you around the Solar System and a Wicked special airs on E! ahead of the film premiere.


My Naam is Farah Teasers - December 2024

Immigration officials turn up at Farah’s home. And then she receives a call from a ghost.


Survivor 45: See who lovestruck Austin's dating now

Are Austin and Dee still together? Find out here as we reflect on the season.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.