SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE



 

A CASE OF STOLEN IDEAS?

Written by SATVCRITIC from the blog TV & FILM REVIEWS on 18 Jan 2017
Favourite this post




I’m down with the flu, and have been booked off work. So I sat down and watched TV this afternoon and one of the movie channels on DSTV was playing one of my favourite movies, Madea’s Big Happy Family.  I always enjoy a good Tyler Perry movie. He finds a way to bring out the best in us darkies and tells universal stories about black life and we can relate to most of his content. This movie is full of characters that are engaging and entertaining, some over the top than others, but nonetheless, they work and suit Perry’s style.
 
Then when I turned to one of the Mzansi channels, unsure if it was Mzansi Wethu or one of the other ones and they played The Gift, which was produced by Ferguson Films whom have produced a lot of shows for Mzansi (Rockville, iGazi, The Queen). In the last few years the Fergusons have become a force to be reckoned with in the industry. I take my hat off for their hard work. They have made a mark in the industry. But there was something that bothered me. The movie had striking similarities to that of Madea’s Big Happy Family. First, the two sisters who live very different lives. The one sister has made it and married to a rich man, while the other one is poor and married a guy from the hood (ekasi) – this could be a coincidence, but then both of the girls who have made it seem to not want anything to do with being back home in both movies, while the one who is poorer is working hard at home but doesn’t seem to get her mother’s recognition.
 



Then there is what seems like a scene stolen right out of Perry’s script. The scene was the huge family dinner. In Perry’s film, Tammy (Natalie Desselle) is fed up of her mother Shirley (Loretta Devine) always favouring the other sister so she rips apart and divulges family secrets about how her big sister Kimberly (Shannon Kane) fell pregnant as a teenager and gave birth to her son Byron (Bow Wow), and he was raised as their brother. In The Gift, Thembi Seete’s character (I think her name was Bontle in the film) she gets the shock of her life when her sister (played by Tsholo Monedi) reveals a big secret that the sister fell pregnant as a teen and their mother knew this secret and concealed it, but in The Gift, Seete aborted her baby.
 
Now this could all be a coincidence, but it is too similar. Someone clearly stole the idea and scenes from another here. With that said, Madea’s Big Happy Family was released in 2011 and The Gift was released in 2014. You be the judge. 



Comments


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Saturday 26 April 2025

Last Chance Love gets a run on Wethu and a new season of Hier Sit die Manne begins on VIA.


Inimba Teasers - May 2025

Things heat up between Zoleka, Hlathi and Qhawe in light of the truth. Does the truth bring darkness?


New! Amalanga Awafani Teasers - April 2025

Troubled twins Thembi and Sabelo fight for their home as a lottery ticket goes missing... a tease of SABC1's new 18h30 novela.


Amalanga Awafani Teasers - May 2025

Thembi faces her overwhelming grief and Sabelo turns to music. They try to find their duck-and-dive father.


Genesis Teasers - May 2025

Gabriel falls to his knees - shattered, desperate. And Mmarona risks everything to keep her secret.


iThonga Teasers - May 2025

Is that Banele? It is! - he makes his presence known to Sanele in the midst of his new big project.


On Carte Blanche: Mayday! South Africa's air traffic controllers flee

An investigation into South Africa’s air safety procedures and the organisation that's failing to maintain them in time.


Diepe Waters Teasers - May 2025

Gys discovers something shocking about Siseko’s wedding - and Siseko confesses to Bandile.


New on TV today: Friday 25 April 2025

Returning reality shows include Kids Baking Championship on Food and The Bad Skin Clinic on TLC.


Smoke & Mirrors 3 Teasers - May 2025

Thandiswa stumbles upon Mpendulo's revealing diary, uncovering a plot that could upend everything.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY


More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS





×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.