SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE
SIGN IN SEARCH MENU
SOUTH AFRICA'S TV WEBSITE


Get your reviews and insights on everything to do with movies and TV, locally and internationally.

Oscar Best Picture Review: Moonlight

Written by tha - bang from the blog Movies and Things with Thabang on 02 Mar 2017
Favourite this post




If you have been reading my Oscar Review specials, you would know that although I liked La la land I didnt believe it should win Best Picture and that honour should go to either The Arrival, Fences or Moonlight. Moonlight came up on top and I'm happy. Let's dig in on why Moonlight was a deserving winner...



In the age of the Donald, fake news has entered the general public's lexicon, intolerance is brewing, LGBTI are targeted in public bathrooms, Mexicans and Muslim people and folks who are not generally Caucasian and "Christian" are not so welcomed in the US no more.

Of course in these times, the dream machine that used to pride itself on producing dramas that spoke to the times and captured the outlooks of generations from The Godfather to Rebel Without a Cause to even Rocky would give the Best Picture to a movie that is very anti-Trump.



So as to sock it to the powers that be and show that even though money runs Hollywood, money loves liberal ideals more than ideas that are more in line with Stalin times than 2017. So that's reason one why Moonlight got that golden statue.

Then there's the story of Moonlight - if black males are trash, black males are "hard criminals", black males are a walking stereotype, a caricature at most and Barry Jenkins and writer / collaborator Tarell Alvin McCraney take the stereotypes of the black male and turns them on their head.

Instead we get fully fledged characters who go up against the stereotype from Mahershala Ali's drug pushing Juan, who is a decent father figure with a very bad job, to the various incarnations of Chiron.

It helps that Barry Jenkins and Tarelll McCraney (whose unpublished play the movie is based on) can call on their own experiences of growing up with a drug addict mother in the streets of Miami. 



We can see it in how the people are portrayed, humanised and questioned. No one is made out to be a saint, they are just people with faults.

We have the troubled inner city child, the angry black woman, the thug young adult and each are given a sense of humanity, sensitivity that they become more than just stereotype. Naomi Harris, who could have ended up as another stereotyped druggie, is given some complexity and she rises to the challenge.

Even though the main character is gay, the film is not framed to be about gay rights but about a journey of self discovery. Mind you, even within the black community here in the SA and in the USA, LGBTI are portrayed for laughs in movies, they are never totally real characters.

Folks that one can identify with or where you get a sense that they are more than just tension release devices or jokes. Barry Jenkins pushes all to the side and turns Moonlight into this year's Boyhood with a character who is gay.



Barry Jenkins takes us into the world of the young man growing up gay in the urban jungle and you have to be Stalin not to be moved by the coming of age story that does not rely on big dramatic moments, shouty acting or hyper dramatic moments to tell a story about a man who is coming to terms with himself.

He could easily fit in but he's looking to find a connection that would let him be himself and you don't have to be gay to get that.

It's a simple story told with heart and it got me sold - I would have loved The Arrival to win but it losing out to a movie with an entirely black cast, written by black guys, directed by a black male in a time where last year people where crying #Oscarssowhite is legendary.

Barry Jenkins became the first African American director to win a Best Picture, it's the first LGBTI film to win Best Picture ever and the first movie with a micro budget of $1.5 m to win Best Picture. These are massive achievements.

I have a feeling 10 years from now we will be talking about how this movie paved the way to showing black people in their different shades of grey and not just how the announcement was bundled.

Rating 
*****
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

* Pap * * It needs a lot of aromat *** we are cooking with gas ****book your ticket ***** Buy this,its a classic



2 Comments

wonderlad
03 Mar 2017 08:59

Well done indeed to Moonlight on it's win! For a small, poetic film to tower over the big publicity machines of big Hollywood is amazing! I thought Naomi Harris was excellent - I am sure that more people will get to see it now. For me, the last act was weaker than the first two - felt that it needed one more Act to make up a better whole (it lacked the cathartic end moments of say Manchester by the Sea or Lion) , but whatever - well done. 

tha - bang
06 Mar 2017 10:25

Hey Wonderlad i hear you ...im looking forward to 2018 oscars they should be very interesting


Only TVSA members can reply to this thread. Click here to login or register.






LATEST ARTICLES

New on TV today: Monday 14 April 2025

New novela Inimba debuts on Mzansi Magic and The Last of Us returns, set five years after Season 1.


New on TV today: Sunday 13 April 2025

ID profiles The Pelicot Rape Case and Titanic: The Digital Resurrection airs on Nat Geo.


New! Awkward Dates Teasers - April 2025

An actress who loves crochet and a politician who wears a hat. Who? See who Lasizwe's "dating".


New! Spreading Humours Teasers - April 2025

This podcast crosses over to two others, with storytelling and performance in between.


New on TV today: Saturday 12 April 2025

Three more podcasts debut on Mzansi Magic and Wethu, as K-drama Resident Playbook drops on Netflix.


Skeem Saam Teasers - May 2025

Pax’s world crumbles as his past mistakes finally catch up with him.


On Carte Blanche: Shot in the foot for private security

South Africa's latest fiasco that has people up in arms. Guns and security companies.


New! Open Chats Teasers - April 2025

Reasons behind dating, football controversies and funny high school stories - topics in this fifth filmed podcast on Wethu.


New on TV today: Friday 11 April 2025

Jon Hamm stars in Your Friends & Neighbors on Apple TV+ as BBC Earth invites Sue Perkins Into Alaska.


Generations character portrait: Thuli Phongolo as Namhla Diale

Namhla's back from the overseas and wants to be Jack's other glove.

LATEST SITE ACTIVITY

FAVESZN replied to the article Skeem Saam Teasers - May 2025
AggieM replied to the article Soapie Digest: April 2025
TheTVFanaticDsk replied to the article Why TVSA no longer reports the TAMS
TVSA Team published an article called New! Awkward Dates Teasers - April 2025 in their blog Awkward Dates
TVSA Team published an article called New! Spreading Humours Teasers - April 2025 in their blog Spreading Humours Teasers
TVSA Team published an article called On Carte Blanche: Shot in the foot for private security in their blog Carte Blanche Teasers
Motungwa added a profile picture
TVSA Team commented on the news headline Uyajola 9/9 and Umndende
TVSA Team published an article called New! Open Chats Teasers - April 2025 in their blog Open Chats
qavile replied to the article Generations character portrait: Thuli Phongolo as Namhla Diale

More activity at TVSA Central



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS



LATEST SOAPIE TEASERS




Thabang Phetla loves movies,
he loves TV...
he loves his writing...
if you love movies and tv
you will definitely love
his writing on movies and TV.
signed by Thabang's Mom
 
×
×

You browser doesn't have Flash, Silverlight, Gears, BrowserPlus or HTML5 support.